Gotcha? Some said a glass of water 'proved' China faked its space station – but simple science destroyed the argument in seconds

Gotcha? Some said a glass of water 'proved' China faked its space station – but simple science destroyed the argument in seconds

A theory online claimed China's space agency was faking its space station – all because of a glass of water. Science debunked the theory

Get monthly inspiration to your door with BBC Sky At Night Magazine - subscribe today


Get the key facts in our 1-minute dive into this story about China's space station

Online claim: Social media users previously shared a conspiracy theory claiming a glass of water on China's Tiangong space station proved its crewed spaceflight program was faked.

Skeptical: Viewers questioned why neither the liquid nor the glass itself floated away in the weightless environment

Key questions: Shouldn't the glass be floating? Why is the liquid resting in the bottom of the glass?

Live broadcast: The contested video originated from a live-streamed science lesson conducted by the Shenzhou-13 crew in late 2021.

AP investigation: The Associated Press debunked the theory in 2023 as part of their ongoing efforts to address widely-shared misinformation.

Surface tension: University of Chicago space historian Jordan Bimm explained that surface tension and molecular attraction keep water clinging to the glass in clumps without dispersing.

Behind scenes: China's space program posted a video showing astronaut Wang Yaping pouring water through a straw and securing a glass with adhesive strips.

Ping-pong test: A follow-up experiment showed a submerged ping-pong ball remaining suspended underwater rather than floating, matching microgravity physics.

External verification: University of Manchester researcher Molly Silk noted that China has little reason to fake footage and the space station's presence is verified by international actors like the US.

Established success: China's sophisticated space program is further demonstrated by major achievements such as the Chang'e 5 and Chang'e 6 lunar missions.

Artist's impression of China's Tiangong space station. Credit: Adrian Mann/Stocktrek Images/Getty Images
Credit: Adrian Mann/Stocktrek Images/Getty Images

Get the all the facts in our full story on the controversy surrounding the glass of water on China's space station

Footer banner
This website is owned and published by Our Media Ltd. www.ourmedia.co.uk
© Our Media 2026