What's the difference between Newton and Einstein gravity?

Newton vs Einstein: what is the major discrepancy between their theories of gravity?

Published: January 28, 2022 at 9:41 am
Get your own Space Pen when you subscribe to BBC Sky at Night Magazine today!

Gravity is one of the trickiest concepts to understand. In our everyday lives it appears relatively weak, yet on cosmological scales it is the strongest, most influential force in the Universe.

Advertisement

Gravity was one of the first forces to be recognised and is at the heart of the first laws of motion to be defined in physics.

Yet despite this, gravity remains one of the least understood forces of all.

The falling apple is now a symbol of Newton's ideas about gravity. Credit: Andreas Coerper Mainz / Getty Images
The effects of gravity are plain to see, but how much do we really understand gravity? Credit: Andreas Coerper Mainz / Getty Images

Yes, gravity may cause apples to fall from trees, our feet to stick to the pavement and the International Space Station to orbit our planet, but if we really analyse it, no such force actually exists.

Two of the biggest figures who have contributed to our understanding of gravity are Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein, and you may have heard how many aspects of their theories don't match.

You may also have heard how Newtonian gravity's inability to explain the orbit of Mercury led to the search for a theoretical planet Vulcan, for example.

What was missing from Newton's theories of gravity, and what are the major differences between his and Einstein's?

Newton vs Einstein: the theory of gravity

Side-by-side portraits of Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein
Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein both contributed hugely to our understanding of gravity, but the two theories have some fundamental differences. Credit: DEA / ICAS94 / Getty Images, MPI / Stringer / Getty Images

Einstein’s theory of gravity, the general theory of relativity, differs in many ways from Newton’s earlier theory of gravity.

One of the most important is that Einstein’s theory incorporates the cosmic speed limit: the speed of light.

Newton had assumed that gravity is felt everywhere in the Universe instantaneously, in other words that it travels at infinite speed.

Newton would therefore have predicted that, if the Sun vanished at this moment, the Earth would notice the lack of gravitational pull immediately and fly off out of the Solar System.

Einstein recognised that since nothing, not even gravity, can travel faster than the speed of light, the Earth would not notice the absence of gravity for 8.5 minutes, the time it takes gravity to travel (at 300,000km/s or 6.7 million mph) from the Sun to the Earth.

An artist's impression of Earth in orbit around the Sun. Credit: janiecbros / iStock / Getty Images Plus
An artist's impression of Earth in orbit around the Sun. Credit: janiecbros / iStock / Getty Images Plus

Another difference between Newton and Einstein is that Einstein’s theory recognises that the source of gravity is not mass, as Newton believed, but energy, one form of which is mass.

This means that all forms of energy have gravity: sound energy, heat energy and so on.

Crucially, gravity itself is a form of energy, so gravity creates more gravity.

What this means is that close to the Sun where solar gravity is at its most powerful, gravity is slightly stronger than Newton predicted.

In Newtonian gravity, a planet can only follow an elliptical orbit, but Mercury’s orbit continually shifts so that it traces out a pattern like a rosette.

The prediction of this ‘precession’ of the perihelion of Mercury was one of the key triumphs of Einstein’s theory of gravity.

Advertisement

This article originally appeared in the December 2006 issue of BBC Sky at Night Magazine.

Authors

Marcus Chown is an award-winning writer and broadcaster and a former radio astronomer at the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena. He is the author of Breakthrough: Spectacular stories of scientific discovery from the Higgs particle to black holes (Faber & Faber, 2021).

Sponsored content